dvis3yzawwgr9p4du4g7rcqsie1vi7

Safety Enigma: “Preaching To The Choir!”

Published on

in

Anyone involved in the FAASTeam or similar safety program knows this story: the pilots showing up for safety presentations are already the safe ones, not the rogues. We are continually “preaching to the choir!” As a frequent presenter, this is frustrating. Our message misses the mark. We need a new methodology to inject safety where it is most needed. We need a way to reach the outliers. With this goal in mind, I now always end my safety presentations with the appeal to all pilots attending to reach out directly to those they know who fly dangerously.

This is a tough job, and somewhat violates some unwritten “pilot code of privacy”  – live and let die?  As a personality type, these pilots are pretty “self-sure” and convinced they have superior methods (and skills). They usually know their way is the better way and safety advice is usually not welcome.

“How many people here have lost a friend or acquaintance in the last year due to an aviation accident?” “How many people were *surprised* at this occurrence?” The takeaway is that we often know who the dangerous pilots are (accident waiting to happen) and these people do not attend safety seminars…

How do we reach the rogues?

Safety programs do very little good if we are just talking to people who are already committed to safety. For the most part, more FAA outreach is probably not the vector to reach these individuals. A characteristic of rogue pilots is anti-authority. It takes every committed (safety-conscious) pilot reaching out personally to affect a change in these (quietly overconfident) pilots.

Dr. Bill Rhodes has identified this personality type in his extensive study of “Scary Pilots.” The only invitation that has a possibility of working is a safety-minded pilot (like the readers of this blog), reaching out directly and quietly motivating these “scary pilots.” Something like “that might not be wise, we don’t want to lose you – we care about your future!” It is a tough love discussion to be sure, and success is uncertain and must be handled carefully. It is important to start with a mutual interest and bonding. Then work carefully to the difficult issues of safety. I often confront some pretty harsh push back when working with FAA violations during “remedial training” (the lucky ones). If you fail to do this and a friend hurts themselves from a stupid pilot trick, you will feel terrible for not making the attempt. My commitment to safety moving forward is: “Friends don’t let friends fly stupid.” Reach out and try to help your neighborhood “scary pilot” – we know who they are. Fly safely out there (and often)!


Join us at Airventure, we are in the Bravo hangar #2081/2 and have great give-aways for new joining and those that support us daily (thank you!)

 

Tickets are on sale now for our SAFE Dinner (Thursday, 24th 5PM) with CPt. Michael Maya Charles presenting; author of “Artful Flying!” Sample a very generous audio sample HERE (and get your ticket to the SAFE dinner HERE)

3 responses to “Safety Enigma: “Preaching To The Choir!””

  1. Brian Lloyd Avatar

    Good morning David. This is a REALLY tough one. I have attempted to reach these people. One was my student who got the nickname (not from me BTW) of “Gotta Go”, only two weeks into his private pilot training. No matter how hard I tried to get through to him that he could exercise restraint when conditions were not favorable, he ignored me. He died in a crash within a year of getting his license and instrument rating. You just can’t get through to some people.

    1. David St. George Avatar
      David St. George

      Yes, bad attitudes can create an impenetrable wall; sorry for your pilot!

  2. Steven D. Avatar
    Steven D.

    Hello David,
    Great article on a tough topic. Your metaphor is good but, it’s a more difficult question to answer than it appears. You state you are always preaching to the choir. Well, choir members gravitate to like minded choir members. Who in a choir wants someone who’s not in tune with them? Rouge pilots want to sing their own music and, maybe the choir does not appeal to them. What needs to be debated is: does it take a choir to turn a rouge pilot around?

Tell us what *you* think!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Thanks for Visiting!

Thank you for visiting the SAFE Blog. There are over 500 specifically tailored articles covering a wide range of aviation issues related to flight training both as a pilot and as a CFI. Search HERE for a specific article, and Join SAFE

Please try our new AI Tool (Chat 5.2 trained on SAFE Blog content) for your specific topics of answers to your aviation questions. SAFE crafted AI Tool


Notification Here!

Stay updated with our latest tips and other news by joining our newsletter.


Free SAFE Toolkit App

Everything a busy CFI needs at their fingertips, *plus* resources for pilot applicants: “Checkride Ready” (with all the DPE advice on how to pass your practical test) FREE Download

Discover more from Aviation Ideas and Discussion!

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading